jibu swali hili

Harry Potter Swali

Where wewe dissapionted with HBP?

I was slightly dissapointed because they cut an awful lot out of the book: There was no Bill and Fleur, Tonks and Lupin and The biggest one....Dumbledores funeral and the white tomb!!!!I know they didnt have enough time but I think that the White Tomb was a crucial scene in this book!!They didnt have to cut it...
 Cullen-fan posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
next question »

Harry Potter Majibu

Bones_love said:
ya!! they could have taken out the things that didnt even happen in the book to make time for the real things... the beggining and end were both totally wrong! wasnt harry supposed to stay at his house and being all sad about sirius dying, not trying to get at girls his whole summer and dumbledore does not just leave harry outside rons house. and in the end they cut out everything!! like harry never finds out about snape being the death eater who heard the prophecy, he never goes to tell ron and hermione to watch out while him and dumbledore are away, harry and dumbledore never go to hogsmeade, there was no fight with the death eaters and the order, and there was no funeral... there was no bill and fleur, lupin and Tonks werent supposed to be together already, and i'm sure there was alot of other things but those were the ones that dissapointed me the most. the only good thing i have to say about th movie is that it was funny.
sorry my answer is so long
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
I REALLY missed the fight...and Dobby too...
martemora15 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
Torsaporsa said:
I was disappointed with the movie. The romance was pretty horribly scripted, and they cut out a ton of stuff. There was no sign of Bill and Fleur. The entire battle scene at the end was cut out, and the death eaters just waltzed out of Hogwarts, after setting moto to Hagrid's cottage(apparently Hagrid didn't notice, because there was no sign of him.)To it's credit, the movie had some funny bits, and nice effects, but as far as accuracy goes, it fails.
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
the_bunkster said:
i personally LOVED it!!!!!! it was my favourite book and i think they did an awesome job!!! best movie so far definately! yeah they missed some stuff out, just like all of the other ones, but it still made sense and they did an awesome job!!! THANK wewe DAVID YATES!!!!
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
good coment i luved it 2
Mugglestar96 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
e2mma2weasle3 said:
yes a little becaus ethe movie they cut out very good things on the book yea like dumbledores funeral and the memories there were zaidi than two memories alisema in the book like the one were they find tom riddles mother's ring and and bill and fleur and a lot of many other awesome things th ewhite tomb and the part were harry attacks draco and snape putas him in detention and he asks for the potions book and then he seens rons name mixed up that would have beeing a good funny seen and when ginny and harry are girlfriend and boyfriend and when ron and harry catch ginny and dean kissing pasionatly and ron and ginny have the fight and when harry pushes ginny and dean when hes coming out of the portrait to see hagrid and hes covered on his invisibility cloack and voldemort wasn't at all in the movie well tom was and voldemort wasn't . and now i wonder if the inayofuata one is gonna be like this hopefuly not because in the inayofuata one it has to onyesha alot zaidi information than this one lol......but apart from that it was funny exciting and awesome also romantic and the way hermione really loves ron and dosn't let him go :D

select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
but it was awesome and i loved it and thank wewe david
e2mma2weasle3 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
AlexRose123 said:
lol sorry guys, i might go into a bit of a mini-rant here (:
well tbh, after like 8 years of the sinema coming out and being not nearly as good as the books, i dont know why i expected this one to be any different. it missed out so much vital information, like the fact that snape was the one who sent harry's parents to their deaths - how are they going to explain why snape came to the good side after they were killed? also, there were only 3 memories, and i was quite looking mbele to the one where they meet marvolo gaunt, but they cut it out, so how do they explain the ring, and the cup that harry is supposed to go after? it was almost as if the sub-plots of the romances between harry and ginny and ron and hermione were zaidi important than the actual story line - telling harry about the horcruxes. i also felt that the true depth of dumbledore's relationship with harry wasnt conveyed enough - they had about 4 scenes together in the film.
also, so much was just made up out of the blue! like the burrow setting on moto - clearly just an excuse for ginny to run out and try to protect harry. and bill and greyback, whats gonna happen about that exactly? lupin and tonks, why were they already together, when they werent meant to become a couple until dumbledores funeral (also missed out, tragically)? but the battle scene is most disappointing, it was so exciting in the book, i almost felt proud of the DA and the Order uniting to fight the death eaters, but instead they just strolled out of the castle, and the duel between snape and harry was poorly done, almost skipped over completely. there was so much wrong with the film, and although it had good moments of humour and was emotional and scary in some parts, the uigizaji seems to have become wooden apart from the following; ron, snape, mcgonagall, dumbledore (to an extent) and malfoy. i just cant stand the way they ruin the memory of the books.

select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
next question »