>I actually am kind of a shabiki of AkuRoku, so I'm not saying this off of anti-ship hate au anything.
>I'm not saying "STOP SHIPPING tHIS NOW wewe GUYS ARE TERRIBLE", either. That would be hypocritical because I ship it myself
>I'm not trying to start anything either, I don't like arguing.
>This wasn't intended to be anti-gay either, because I'm pansexual and that would literally be like bashing on myself.
>This is all opinion. If wewe REALLY don't want to agree, that's okay.
So originally, I had written this in the maoni of a poll, but realised it was getting way too big for just a comment, LOL. For a long time, people always have spread a rumor that Sora, Riku, Roxas and Axel were intended to be gay, but was hidden/toned down kwa Square Enix because Disney wouldn't approve. But while Disney not approving would be true, their relationship was probably never meant to be "gay". And now, here's my explantion why.
It seems that many mashabiki aren't aware that there are cultural ideas different from their own.
In Japanese cultures, it's been maarufu to explore super close relationships between males for centuries. There is evidence of this in paintings and vitabu from many centuries back, even. Whiles they sometimes are, these relationships generally aren't actually gay, and occasionally in these stories both men end up getting married to women, etc. anyways (not against their will, I might add). The Japanese like the teasing of a close relationship that isn't explicitly romantic/sexual. wewe probably might notice this relationship in other animes and Japanese games.
The best example in maarufu anime would be Hikaru and Kaoru Hitachin, the twins in "Ouran High School Host Club". They are NOT gay for each other, and one (or both?) has a crush on the main girl character, as well. And yet they still have a really close relationship that appears to be gay; they DO upendo each other, because they are brothers and they're always together since they're twins, but it's not a homosexual relationship. And they are both fully aware that people are attracted to the idea. which is why they do it in front of the girls, and the girls upendo it. Because that's what the Japanese like. They are actually the manga artist's parody on the idea.
But that idea doesn't exist in Western culture/tropes (aka anywhere that's not Asia). Either he's your friend/family, au you're gay for him; there isn't leeway and there isn't an in between, that's the way it exists in the West. Because of that, when western mashabiki saw the relationships between Sora and Riku, and Roxas and Axel, it appeared to be gay -- because we never explore the concept of an in between.
There isn't really a word for it in the English language either, which makes it all the zaidi difficult. People naturally have to stick labels on things. That's how they know what's what, and how to feel about this au that. When something doesn't have a clear name, they will stick it to the closest thing they know. For some fans, the closest thing they knew was "close friends". For others, it was "gay". And that's how the shipping war starts.
And that's what puts these characters in jeopardy in Disney's eyes. Not because they're gay, but because Disney knows that people in the West will THINK they are gay, for lack of a better word. And they don't want that trouble. Which, yes, is still homophobic, and sucks, obviously.
Now, that isn't to say wewe can't ship it anyways, because shipping is fun. But arguing that it's canon, I think, is pretty ridiculous. I also encourage people to make their own makala about their opinion on these things, too! Whether wewe agree au disagree with me.
If wewe want me to elaborate, let me know! And please, don't be immature??