I think that the other deaths had more inpact and at least you could get a sort of lesson out them. On the other hand, if Claire and Aaron don't get rescued, Charlie had a meanigless death too, he died to save Claire and Aaron

I love Boone! He's so hot when he died I cried I want him to come back to life

I guess I would say Shannon second. Charlie's death was exceptionally meaningful. Boone was a "sacrifice that the island demanded", so that was meaningful. In a way Libby and Ana were necessary to show just how determined Michael was. I just think that Eko's death felt rushed and unexplained. Still waiting to see how they're going to explain why the smoke monster would initially leave him alone only to kill him later. Nikki and Paulo's deaths were brilliant.

You make a good point nosemuffin

Though I did like Libby.

She wasn't even in it that much bit I still liked her..

God, I can't choose. I never realized that there were this many senseless deaths in the show.

i ddnt like shanon bt she ddnt dserve 2 die

i believe that libby will still be a major part of the story

shes was linked to too many people off the island to not

ana lucia was pointless and it was a death we wanted pretty much

shannon's was really meaningful, come on, artz wasnt sad at all!!

shannon's dead was very meangfull. i think the most meaningless dead was Libby's ( i hardly remember how she was look like). i think ana lucia's died was meaningfull only because he took that she deserved for shannon's death. i mean come on shannon the best in lost she killed her off. i was so happy when ana lucia died

fine, charlie's death was "meaningful" but everyone (the watchers of lost) loved him, so I still don't understand why they killed off such an amazing character!

^Iol....no one I knew liked him, infact my friends named him PSH; "possessive snarky Hobbit"

Anyways, I always thought Libby's was so pointless, but I think it was more of a political statement for ABC not to condone DWI'S while filming sadly.

I Heard Charlie Isnt Dead Or Claire.