Snow and I've stated why on the other polls, I'm too lazy to type it again haha. I really think she should be out by now. Clearly didn't get her mothering from her mother :P

17. Ruth
18. Henry Sr
19. Rumple
20. Edwin
21. Maurice
22. Anita
23. Lady Tremaine
24. Cora
25. Milah
24. Alphonse
25. Martin & Myrna (Jiminy's Parents)
26. King George
27. Pan/ Malcolm
28. The Sultan

We don't ever see Granny and Anita together but we know she stole her daughter from her which is pretty terrible. Also she lied to Red (her adopted daughter). I know she was trying to protect her but if Granny had just told her the truth she would have known why it was so important for her to wear the cloak and the whole Peter incident never would have happened. Also I've never gotten over the way she always seemed to be putting Ruby down and telling her that her dreams and ambitions were silly and never going to happen during season one.

Was she an adoptive mother to Red? She was just her Granny I think. I have a friend who has been living with her gran ever since she was born, due to something that happened with her mother. She has never been her adoptive mother either, just her gran.

@Evilregal14 I think Granny, Cinderella (almost sold her kid), Mr Tillman/Woodcutter (didn't even want to see the children that might or might not be his) and maybe Leopold (he spoiled Snow real good) should go out first. Then I'd be fine with Snow getting eliminated because all the rest are as good or better.

I wasn't asking about Snow though lol, I was talking about Red and Granny.

I count Red as her child because she raised her and was her main guardian. I have a friend that was raised by her grandparents as well (because her mom basically dumped her on them) and her grandmother was always more of a mother to her then her actual mom ever was even though she still called her grandma.

Also being a good or bad grandparent counts in this poll IMO as its just an extention of parenting. It's grandparenting.

Yeah, I can see your point. Red might see her as a mother figure but the writers will probably never show how she feels about her. I loved their conversation in 1x15 when Ruby said she was a tough act to follow. I'm just glad Ruby has SOMEONE lol. She's in the minority of people that aren't related to Henry. While everyone is trying to figure out how they're favorite is related to Henry, I'm just like "Well my favorite is Ruby so..."

My favorite is Red too. I also really like the little moments her and Granny have together. They clearly have a very special bond. You can tell Granny would literally do anything for Ruby and vis versa. It's just not in her personality to tell her that. She doesnt have that warm and loving personally that women who where just born to be mothers seem to have.

I loved their argument at the start of 1x15 too. They just have a really realistic grandmother/granddaughter relationship IMO. Arguing then making up soon after.

Just asking what did Jefferson do to get votes? He's by far the best imo

I think the best are Ruth, Eva and Marco. Maybe people are voting since he left Grace (I know it's mainly Regina's fault but some people overlook that)

^^ Possibly because he didn't go find Grace the instant the curse was broken, but I agree he is one of the best. My #1 is Robin.

What I find odd is that Neal almost won last time. Not exactly sure why (I think he was a great dad) but he was really close to getting eliminated. Now he has zero votes. Last weeks episode must have really turned people around.

Someone said he shouldn't even be considered a dad yet? They might only be on season 1/2 though, because he is definitely a dad and a good one. He tried to be a good dad from the moment he saw him in Manhattan.

He never really got to spend a lot of time with Henry but that wasn't his fault he did everything in his power to be with him.

The only thing that annoyed me was that scene in the Forest of Shadows when he was trying to impress Emma. The only thing he should have been worrying about was Henry not weather Emma was interested in Hook or not. Emma was by far the best parent in that episode when she said the only person she was interested in was Henry.

That was the dark hollow episode right? He did well protecting Henry in Neverland. Trying to get him to safety and everything. I think Emma is a pretty bad parent most of the time. She just doesn't seem like his parent, more like his sister half the time.

That was it "Dark Hollow" I was not impressed with him in that episode. Also after Neverland he should have been spending time with his son who had just been though an trauma that he in particular could sympathize with. Instead he was trying to set up a date with Emma.

That's his one downfall as a parent IMO. Emma didn't ask him to come back for her she wanted him to be there for Henry. He should have respected that and focused on getting to know the son he barely knew rather then trying to win her back. His inability to respect her wishes is kind of what turned me off Swanfire. That is until his final episode. That last scene they had together was perfect. When they were joking around about there love lives and he told her that as long as she was happy he was happy even if she ending up with someone else. I wish he had survived so we could have seen that friendship develop. It just feels like the only way romantic relationships can end on this show is tragically. It would have been nice to have a heathy post-lovers relationship.

Minverdawn- ah I see but I think he thought he was doing what was right for her and I agree Robin is awesome as well

I think it's weird that Mr. Tillman has had like no votes so far and then he suddenly now is leading in the poll..lol.

I didn't find him to be that bad...it would be a lot to take in if someone came to you and said "You have homeless twins who are relying on you" out of the blue. Maybe people just forgot about him.

The round really feels out of place with Neal getting no votes when he almost won last time and and Mr. Tillman getting all the votes all of a sudden. He was prob just looked over last time. I mean he did refuse to even meet the kids that could have been his.