just curious..:]

brooke hasnt got a main story line
if they killed haley nathan and jamie will be scared for life
same thing with nathan
if hey kill lucas one tree hill will be over
if they kill peyton leyton fans will kill themselves
if they kill brooke well nobody will be to trametised except brucas fans

7326 brucas fans would be more scarred then if Haley was killed off because most fans have their ship of leyton and brucas then theres some minor people who have Naley. Haley is awsome but it would affect the show the least, Nathan and Jamie will recover. Jamie spends more time with Brooke and Skills anyways. If they kill Lucas OTH is over. If they kill Nathan well he started off as just as important as Lucas but not anymore so I'm not sure. If they kill Peyton it would be a rip off the OC and the show is dead. If they kill Brooke she is a popular character too not sure what would happen but fans would not be very happy. Haley is the least popular character and most of her scenes are her giving advice she never has that many issues of her own, it would be good too them saying how they never listened to Haley's problems just dished their own problems to her lol.

Brucas fans would probably choose Peyton
Naley and Leyton fans would choose Brooke
people who are looking to break up the one good relationship in OTH would probably pick Nathan or Haley

I chose Lucas, because hes being a prick, and I dont feel like he has much more to give the series

i think it would be her because that would effect everyone pretty bad

i have to dissagre with you Mar4ever, Brooke's death would only affect Peyton and probably Haley. The only two people who can affect everyone pretty bad are Haley (Nathan, Jamie, Lucas, Peyton and Brooke) and Lucas (Brooke, Peyton, Haley, Nate and Jamie) the other would affect someone but not all the important characters.

i agree alessandra_28 but i think Peyton would also affect alot of them too..Lucas, Brooke, Haley, Nathan..she's had some sort of a relationship with all of them..

yeah...I forgot to write that. Then is Lucas, haley and Peyton and maybe Nate too but Brooke not

i think peyton

um..i disagree ^^

Brooke Death Would Affect Alot Of People

Brucas Fans:D
Lucas
Haley
Jamie
Mouth
Rachel
Nathan
Peyton
COB (Clothes Over Bros)
Owen
Karen
Skillz


Peyton
Lucas
Haley
Skillz
Larry

That About It

She Wasnt Close With Mouth,Rachel,Jamie

Maybe Karen

I think Brooke because i see her as the least important character in the show. I like Brooke but I don't think she is a huge part of the show. I mean if Lucas died there would be no Leyton or Brucas and the shows ratings would probably drop.

lik alessandra_28 and tvfan5 said. lucas and haley would affect the other main 4, along w/other smaller but very important characters (lik jamie!!) and peyton would too!

Seddie4ever, Lucas is the main if he dies then oth is over!!

Brooke is the most un needed.
Everyone else is too important to be booted off.
Although I would miss Brooke if she left!!

OMG AS IF BROOKE!
Should be Peyton IMO.

Brooke is the least valuable to the story line!

The Minuite Brooke Is Killed Off - The Minuite I Stop Watching

How Could They Kill Off Such An Important Character?

I Would Have To Choose Peyton To Be Killed Off As It Would Effect The Whole Season - Which Girl (B/P/Lin) Lucas Calls

mizzfelisha you made peytons list wayyy to small!!!

first of all you can add brucas fans to brookes list but you cant add leyton fans to peytons list???? YOU KNOW FULL WELL YOU PICKED HER CAUSE YOU DONT LIKE HER! I KNOW I CANT TALK, BUT STILL, YOUR CHOICE IS SO BIASED!


okay heres peytons real one:

LEYTON FANS
PEYTON FANS
lucas
BROOKE (you missed off)
nathan
haley
skills
karen
larry
HER MUSIC COMPANY
MIA
TRIC ... no peyton, no tric
owen ... no tric, no owen
MUSIC .... how else would they fit the artists that appear into the storylines without peyton/tric!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!OTH!!!!!!!!!!! IT WOULD TOTALLY RUIN OTH!!! YOU SAW WHAT OC WAS LIKE WHEN MARISSA GOT KILLED OFF AND I DIDNT EVEN FULLY LIKE HER!!! KILLING THE MAIN GIRL OFF IS SUICIDE FOR THE SHOW!!! I THINK THE ONLY SHOW THAT SURVIVED IT WAS CHARMED! AND THAT WAS CAUSE THEY GOT A BETTER REPLACMENT!!! YOU COULD NEVER REPLACE PEYTON!! IM SORRY NO WAY!! SHE IS ONE OF THE TWO FAVOUIRTE CHARACTERS (BROOKE AND PEYTON)!! SOME PEOPLE HATE HER BUT WHEN IT COMES DOWN TO WHO PEOPLE LIKE HER - THE FANS OVERRULE THE ONES WHO DONT!!!! PEYTON AND LUKE ARE THE MOST VALUABLE TO THE SHOW!!!!

I THINK THE LEAST VALUABLE IS NATE/HALEY/BROOKE!!! BUT THE WRITERS ARE GIVING HER BETTER STORYLINES NOW SO I THINK SHE COULD IMPROVE! SO OUT OF NATE AND HALEY - IT WAS A TOSS UP!! HAHA YOU ALL KNOW IM LIEING!! - I PICKED HALEY CAUSE I DIDNT LIKE HER!! BUTT I GAVE GOOD REASONS FOR WHY THE REST OF THEM SHOULD STAY!!! NOT LIKING HER HELPED ME MAKE A DECISION!!!

too be honest - i cant believe nate is bottom and peyton is second!!!
shouldnt it be the other way around???? i know people like nate but sheeeshh hes as useless as haley!

haley. just to see how everyone would cope without her. she's lucas' best friend, nathans wife, jamie's mother etc. i think she's probably the one with the most ties with the other characters. i think peyton would be interesting as well.
i think brookes death would be the least interesting. her death wouldnt bring anything to the show because she's not as involved in the main storylines at the moment or not as 'needed'. if you want to kill a main character off you should pick someone who will majorly shake up the storylines, and brookes death wouldnt necessarily.

i totally agree with you Laurra. just cause you don't like a character shouldn't mean that that should be your answer.

Laurra has a good point. Though, i still think it be wrong to kill of any of them. I still think brooke is the least important one.

wow strong feelings here ... yeah i agree with leytonfan4ever ... don't kill anyone! but why picked peyton was if i was a writer i'd say her death would effect people the most, stir things up, be really tragic for lucas ... but i don't want her to die!
but strangely enough ... that doesn't make a brucas fan! i love leyton!

I think it would be Brooke but I'd rather it was Peyton if it was to happen.