Love Homecoming as well. But the first was definetly the scariest.

I really like SH3,SH2,and Homecoming. Hate SH4 I don't really consider it to be a part of the series,the storyline to me seems way off of the normal story.

Silent Hill 3 was the only game so far that actually continued the storyline of a previous game in the series,had awesome graphics,an awesome soundtrack,etc.

Haven't played all of them, but this is definitely my favorite out of the ones I played.

le 2 est le plus émouvant et le plus effrayant, le 4 est gore et malsain. ce sont mes préférés de la série. et les deux "héros" sont les plus beaux et les plus intéressants psychologiquement !

The second one is just... overrated.
Heck, if it weren't for Silent Hill 3, I wouldn't have been a Silent Hill fan in the first place.

SH4 is the somewhat different game in the series but haven forbid they tired something new. But SH4 is part of the series with such connections like

1. Walter Sullivan was first referenced in a newspaper scrap in Silent Hill 2 as having killed himself shortly after killing twins Billy and Miriam Locane. These two victims also appear in the form of the "twin victim" creature Henry encounters.
2. Walter Sullivan’s gravesite is visible in the graveyard later on in SH2.
4. The investigative journalist Joseph Schreiber, was first referenced in Silent Hill 3 with a magazine article he has written condemning the Hope House orphanage run by The Order which the game's protagonist, Heather, can discover at Brookhaven Hospital.
3. Frank Sunderland is the father of James Sunderland from SH2. He is said to have disappeared in Silent Hill together with his wife several years ago.
5. The Robbie The Rabbit doll can be seen sitting on Eileen’s the bed. Robbie has appeared in SH3, SH: The Arcade and SH: Homecoming.
6. The Halo of the Sun, first appearing in SH3, is seen during the loading screen and are the holes which Henry uses to travels between his apartment and Walter's world.