Okay I got into the series pretty late and I knew both guys were alive and okay. But this scene still made me so sad, even through I knew Sam was going to come back. I think what makes this really sad to me is two things. The fact that it wasn't really expected. and second Jensen's acting in that scene, he was so heart breaking it was unreal. Dean's death made me mad, but I knew it was going to happen, even through I was waiting to see it they would get him out of it in the end, obliviously they didn't. But it think it's safe to say these boys are the poster children for the supernatural, they have more lives than a cat. But still this scene killed me, hell all the scenes were they die or are fighting kills me!:(

Both were sad. Sam's was more unexpected but Dean's was sad because of his goodbye with Sammy :-(

I cry every time i watch this episode... :(