Okay, so first of all for me it's not like simply saying Bella because this is the Twilight spot au such things. I've seen and read both, the Twilight Saga and the Host and I loved both! I really like Melanie, but I have to go for Bella. With Bella, for me it's like wewe can realte to her so easily. So, if I really have to choose, I'd pick Bella though I really like Melanie!