smack down status: it's witch vs fighter (to clarify squads normally consist of four)
tara won cordelia by 64%
the initiative fighters won dawn and xander by 75%

I'm gonna go with Tara...even though she doesn't realize it she's a super powerful witch. I think she could hold her own in a fight with the initiative. However, I'm not completely set. If you present the initiative side well enough, I might change my mind :) But for now, I'm sticking with the witch

she was killed by a gun! the initiative are like 4 guys running round with state of the arts guns! so working it out im guna go with the dudes!

Depends on who had the draw. Magic totally beats, but she's one and they're a squad and physically, she's got nothing.

she was killed my a gun on the off chance, it could have killed powerful willow, or buffy herself just as easily,
i think the way this weighs out is although tara has the power she does not have the want to fight, where as the inciative will just follow any orders, but i guess if driven to she would fight
hmmmmm....

it has to be tara! she did die because of a gun, but that was because she wasn't looking.

she uses harmless magic, fightmagic isn't in her