Disney Princess Would wewe like it if i started a best dress countdown?

This question is now closed
27 fans picked:
Yes!
   56%
No!
   44%
 BB2010 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

46 comments

user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
I tried starting a countdown but I kept getting comments on what to do to improve it or that it's been already done and other stuff. I just wanted to start this pick and see if any of you guys actually want to have a countdown like this

the pick I tried to make was which princess had the best outfit/dress in different versions like regular dress or formal dress or outfit worn in a bad situationn (kinda like Next Top Model) and to do that I need people to choose their least favorite outfit listed in the picks. I also wanted the princess part of the pick to be the forgotten princesses that were never made "official" like Princess Melody and Princess Kida

so that's pretty much it. any comments or questions?
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
Tigressfan10689 picked Yes!:
With all the princesses and non princesses, that would be awsome
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
firegirl1515 picked Yes!:
Exactly which "forgotten princesses" will you be using? Like, will you be using non-princesses and sequel girls?
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
well, I was hoping to mostly use princesses that actually were princesses by birth instead of just being the female lead of a disney movie like Mulan was. For example, Princess Kida was a princess by birth but she's a forgotten princess instead of an "official" princess like the other princesses by birth like Ariel and Jasmine. I could use non princesses if I was gonna use Mulan
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
firegirl1515 picked Yes!:
^^Oh okay. So will you be using Mei, Ting Ting, and Su from Mulan 2, Elionwy from The Black Cauldron, and Maid Marian from Robin Hood since they're all princesses?

Sorry, I just got confused because of the Esmeralda icon, since she's a non-princess.
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
I choose Esmeralda icon for yes because she's my favorite female lead in a disney movie I'm not exactly a fan of Tiana so that's why I used her for no
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
firegirl1515 picked Yes!:
^^Ohhh, okay. But will you be using the five I mentioned in my last comment?
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
princesslullaby picked No!:
I was gonna say, there was already a best dress countdown for the princesses. Technically, this would go in the "Disney Leading Ladies" or "Disney Extended Princesses" section since there was already one for the princesses and you want to do the disney non princesses too.
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
last edited zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
I never heard that comment before when I made the best dress countdown earlier, the only one I've seen was mine

and why should it be in Disney Leading Ladies section when i've mentioned that I'm planning on putting in disney princesses? also, Mulan's not a princess and yet here she is as a princess so why shouldn't I put in Esmeralda or Meg?

btw firegirl1515 I might use the five you mentioned. I'll need to think about it
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
last edited zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 
user photo
firegirl1515 picked Yes!:
^^Ah, the Mulan issue again. I suggest you look here for input on that: link
Because we go by Disney's rules here, Esme and Meg aren't in the lineup.

I told you once before during the other version that I had done a traditional countdown about this (the article is here: link), but I don't mind if you do another since it's in a different type of countdown, like a reality game show.
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
last edited zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
well on the Mulan issue, I kinda already knew that but some people just don't get it I thought there was actually another reason
and about your version of the countdown, I totally forgot about that
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
last edited zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 
user photo
princesslullaby picked No!:
Look at the lineup banner, go to the disney princess site. Mulan is considered a disney princess. This section of fanpop is specifically for the 9 Official Disney Princesses, ONLY. That's why it was saying it should go in the "Disney Leading Ladies" spot, because that includes ALL the disney heroines, not JUST the princesses. I already did a countdown on Best Disney Princess Dresses, which includes the 9 Official Disney Princesses, which is what this section of fanpop is about. This is the article:
link
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
Mulan's an official princess because her movie did well and because people bought a lot of the merchandise whereas the other "non official" princesses like Kida, Meg, Esmeralda, and Eilonwy were forgotten because not enough merchandise was sold and a lot of people didn't like their movies
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
firegirl1515 picked Yes!:
^^Which is why Disney didn't put them on the lineup, therefore you and princesslullaby are both right.
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
princesslullaby was saying I should put this countdown in the Leading Ladies spot because the other girls I was going to put in weren't official princesses which doesn't really seem fair because this is a Disney princess spot and yet Mulan is not a princess by birth or marriage so how exactly is it fair to keep out Kida and Eilonwy?
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
firegirl1515 picked Yes!:
^^We play by Disney's rules here. This is the Official Disney Princess Spot, therefore we only use Official Disney Princesses. It's been that way since the beginning- just ask princesslullaby. We didn't make up the lineup, we just follow it.
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
princesslullaby picked No!:
I've probably been on this spot longer than most of you guys, (not bragging or anything) and I can say that since I've been on here (when we only had a meager 7ish regular users), we've been sticklers for using the OFFICIAL disney princesses, the ones in the banner. This spot is specifically for the OFFICIAL disney princesses. That's why we're asking you to put this countdown in the Disney Leading Ladies Spot, which, again, includes ALL the princesses & non princesses of disney.
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
last edited zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 
user photo
ppv picked No!:
Agree with princesslullaby!
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
alafastanzio picked No!:
I'm with PrincessLullaby on this. I also have probably been here longer than most of you and frankly I'm sick to death of all these countdown repeats and countdowns in general. This spot specifically pertains to the OFFICIAL Disney Princess FRANCHISE and including any of the so-called "forgotten" or "technical" princesses really messes up things in say the Quiz questions because people aren't entirely sure who are considered 'Disney Princesses' on this spot. So please, if you do insist on including anyone other than Snow White, Cinderella, Aurora, Ariel, Belle, Jasmine, Pocahontas, Mulan, Tiana or Rapunzel...do the countdown on the Disney Leading Ladies Spot. That's what its there for.
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
well if this spot is for official disney princesses then why isn't it CALLED the official disney princess spot instead of just disney princess that can get newbie confused

also, during the four months I've been here the only countdowns I've seen were "which palace would you like to live in" or "who has the prettiest hair" or "who sings the best" and I have NEVER not once EVER seen a countdown for best dress.

when was PrincessLullaby's countdown set up anyway? no one's ever actually mentioned it

posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
last edited zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
okay if it will make everybody feel better, I just made this pick in the leadling ladies spot.
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
last edited zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 
user photo
cromulanfav picked No!:
Oh, you just didn't say that to alafastanzio! He has yellow medal, so he knows what he's talking about. I did countdown for their official dresses, and princesslullaby for all of their dresses. And it was somewhere on February or March, I believe. And, scroll this page up, you see the banner, those are the princesses that are included in official line, others don't count
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
cromulanfav picked No!:
And, you know, the point of pick is to other people enjoy, so yeah, you should listen what makes them happy, I don't think that Atlantis sucks, but I also don't think that Kida should be in the line, there are multiple reasons for that
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
I know that. I try really hard to give people what they want but then people keep giving me more comments on what to do to improve it and some of them wait to actually tell me it's already been done. It also gets stressful when some people are really rude about it. also, alafastanzio is saying that he's all sick and tired of all the repeat countdowns and I'm just thinking "it's not like I can automatically know if a countdown of this is already made" and it's not like when you sign up for this website, you don't automatically get a list of picks and countdowns that are already done! And I think it's pretty unfair that mulan is counted a princess even though she wasn't born one or married a prince, she's only an official princess because her movie made a lot of money. And no wonder I've never seen yours or princesslullaby's countdowns I started coming to this website in march

what are the reasons that Kida shouldn't be in the line?
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
last edited zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
also, it'll be really hard to do a countdown in the leading ladies spot since not that many people come there. my last countdown from a month ago is still on the first page of the picks. I would try putting this in the extended princess spot but they would tell me the same thing about the "official" princesses and then I'll be right back where I started from
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
cromulanfav picked No!:
Here is the forum where you can check which the dresses have been made: link I'm not going to explain why Mulan is here, also Pocahontas, and why Kida isn't, but here are some things that people agree what makes princess:
*She has to be main character of the movie
*Has princessy clothes
*Is royalty
*Is popular
*Her story is important for the culture
and there were some more reasons, but I forgot. Kida maybe royalty, but she isn't anything else from the list, Mulan for example is popular, is main character, and her story is quite important and inspirational, at least to me, Pocahontas too
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
last edited zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
after reading that list I can say that it's all been done. God helps the next person who tries to make a countdown that's already been done. Too bad too. A lot of those countdowns look really fun to do. I know I definetely had fun doing the best dress countdown a couple months ago.

Pocahontas I know is here because she's technically a princess since her father is the chief but last time I checked, Jasmine wasn't really a main character of the movie neither was Aurora to tell you the truth, she didn't even get that much screen time compared to Philip and the good fairies and Maleficent
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
last edited zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 
user photo
DreamyGal picked No!:
I picked no, b/c there's been plenty of countdowns done on this subject...EVEN for sequels!
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
yes, DreamyGal I got that the first ten times. Thanks anyway :)
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
cromulanfav picked No!:
Yeah, but Aurora and Jasmine content other things from the list, they are popular, they are royalty, they have nice dresses, their stories are well known...
And if you are creative enough you can always figure of making another countdown, people are still making them.
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
DreamyGal picked No!:
I'm not trying to be mean, and if you chose to do a countdown anyways I would vote and comment...what about a best dressed list for supportive characters? I don't think anything like that has been done before...here's a link to a countdown of the prettiest supporting characters...just to give you a few ideas :)

link
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
cromulanfav, some of the ones I actually thinking of making are already on the list. I honestly can't think of any that aren't on that list or aren't curently being done

DreamyGal, I know you're not trying to be mean. and even if I made that countdown how would I set it up? There are hardly any disney movies where the supporting characters are humans. The only supporting characters I can think of are Charlotte, the seven dwarves, and the good fairies and that would be a little hard since the good faires where the same thing, the same with the dwarves
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
last edited zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 
user photo
princesslullaby picked No!:
Oh hon! I have a RED medal...which is actually sort of sad, so I think I know what I'm talking about... LOL
We can't change the title of this spot, but the banner makes it clear that it's just meant for the 9 official disney princesses. I don't know why you are so upset over this, why it matters so much what spot you are doing it in? is it DIRE that you do it in this spot?
Secondly, no one has mentioned my countdown because it happened awhile ago.
Thirdly, I think DreamyGal has given you a good idea.
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
DreamyGal picked No!:
A red one? Wow. That IS sad ;) I'm one to talk...I'm on my way to one...I'm on here all the effin time! And thanks! I thought it was a good idea too...might do it myself later on...
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
like I said to your comment on the childhood heroines spot, I want to make sure my countdown will actually be voted on. I mean, every other countdown I've made turned out to be in spots that aren't visited in. I mean, I made a countdown in the animated movies spot and only three people voted in it and it was a week long pick too. I wanted to do this countdown in the extended princesses spot and the leading ladies spot but nobody visits those spots as much they used to.

Also, I agree with you, DreamyGal gave me a wonderful idea. It would be a little hard to set it up because most supporting characters are animals like Abu, Rajah, and Meeko and some just don't wear clothes at all like Mrs. Potts. Also, I don't really want to do a countdown she thought up, it wouldn't be right. She should do it since it was her idea :)
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
last edited zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 
user photo
princesslullaby picked No!:
Then do it in the Classic Disney spot! That should get you a lot of voters!
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
DreamyGal picked No!:
Well, I'm already doing 2 other countdowns...I honestly don't mind it...I was just trying to throw out ideas :)
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
DreamyGal picked No!:
princesslullaby is right...you could do it on there...and to draw attention, just post a pick like most of us do...for example, like this one I did...

link

Even though it's going on in another spot, advertise it on here.
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
I just went up there and I decided to do a different countdown. like you guys said before it's been done. I've decided to do a countdown on disney's transformation moments since I've only seen it once or twice during my time here and they were in completely different spots. I just did a pick there asking if they'd like it if I did a countdown like that and so far people are liking it, hopefully no one's already done that countdown there yet
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
princesslullaby picked No!:
^^actually.....I did a countdown on disney princess transformation moments. -_- There's an article too....
Unless you're doing it in the disney spot?
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
DreamyGal picked No!:
^ I think she's doing it in the Classic Disney Spot...
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
ppv picked No!:
@BB2010:
"I hope that the people who think that princess Kida and princess Eilonwy shouldn't be here cuz their movies sucked so they're not "official princesses" is happy."
If Disney didn't include them in this official lineup, it doesn't mean we think they sucked.
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
last edited zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
in the classic disney spot. I read the article that had the list of all the countdowns that have already been done and seeing the DP transformation countdown gave me an idea to do it in the classic disney spot.

btw, what countdowns have you NOT done, princesslullaby? lol ^_^

ppv I wasn't saying that you guys said it, it's actually kinda true. Eilonwy, Kida, Melody, and other forgotten princesses are pretty much not official because their movies didn't do well and they didn't sell enough merchandise
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
last edited zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 
user photo
princesslullaby picked No!:
HHAHA! I tried to do the main ones, the important ones, I think they're fun, but I think after the two I'm doing are done I'm going to take a break. :D

Just so you know, if Kida was a disney princess, she would be second on my list. I LOVE her!
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
BB2010 picked No!:
she's so cool isn't she? That's why I was trying so hard to put her on here :P she's my absolute favorite
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.
 
user photo
alafastanzio picked No!:
Lol us older people were newbies once and over time it became clear that keeping with the franchise "princesses" helps maintain continuity and consistency. I even dabbled with the unofficial princesses and humored the idea of including Nala, Faline, and Maid Marian. I've found that a majority of people don't have an invested interest for them when they join this site.

I really shouldn't have meant to discourage the creation of a new Countdown. But frankly, it seems all the major ones have been done. However other people have done following countdowns that are so similar that some people don't even see the point in participating. For example someone does "Best Princess Dress" and then someone else does "Best Dressed Princess" followed by "Prettiest Outfit". Its to the point where if I see a Countdown including words like Prettiest, Hair, Eyes, Dress, Kiss, Song...I sorta skip it. I would LOVE to see something totally new.

It IS unfair being a newbie as you didn't get to participate in past countdowns and unless you're willing to go through EVERY old article or pick, you may never know it ever existed.
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita.