I don't think she would like his lying.

Don't understand why people think she'd like him...

She would probably not think he's very brave, at least next to Aladdin. she'd find him a bit arrogant when he accidentally insults Pocahontas.

I have stated why before. I don't think she would like or enjoy him as much as John Smith. What do they really have in common?

I don't think Aladdin should be here. Philip deserved to be in second place but anyway.
Merida and John Smith have lots in common. They both changed throughout their movie. They both have an adventurous spirit and are brave. John Smith saved his friend twice and also chief Powhatan and put his life in danger, even in death (if it wasn't luck and Pocahontas) and he knew it while he was doing it. A horrible death really -> being beaten to death, getting a bullet, almost drown.

Aladdin, on the other hand, what does he have in common with Merida? Well, he's brave but not as brave as John Smith and I don't see any similarities between them. Merida doesn't want the traditional life in palace, whereas Aladdin dreams of a life like that, with a princess in a palace, surrounded by hundreds of servants.
She wouldn't be keen on his lies,too.

Still voting for him...

^^ I agree 100%

So, well, it's tied!!!