RESULTS:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5. 2015 Disneyland
6. 2018 Disney Parks

The 2015 doll was eliminated basically unanimously. The remaining dolls are all pretty enough, but I'll go with the Platinum doll; I like the details of the skirt but the rest of the dress isn't that remarkable. I think the others have more appealing colors or designs. Also, it's the only one of these that isn't directly based from any outfit she wore during the movie.

I don't love the dress, or the color honestly.

I just don't like this.

This one.

I like it but the bodice and sleeves are too plain.

Btw they just released pics of the new limited edition dolls for Jasmine, Giselle, and Merida. This is Giselle's first 17 inch doll. You can add Jasmine and Merida to their polls when it's their turns.

It looks worse on the doll than it does on the clip art and as a cosplay dress. The skirt piece is more red than pink.

^I think in the actual movie her dress really is a reddish pink. It's only in the clipart that she wears bubblegum pink.