jibu swali hili

Eragon Swali

I was wondering why wewe guys hate the movie Eragon but not the book...?

I saw the maoni from this fanpage, and all of these are NEGATIVE... I was puzzled and thought, 'Why did they hate the movie?'

I haven't read the book but I already watched the movie... On the comments, some say that the movie Eragon has a bad story, au stupid mistakes... But for me, I did see anything wrong from the movie. :((
I don't want read the book 'cause it's too long au expensive, wewe know.
 Pauline_15 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
next question »

Eragon Majibu

silverstream101 said:
the book really isnt that long...and just go 2 the libraary and borrow it...but this is why i dont like the movie

Well...they didnt even get Arya right! shes not surposed 2 b that old... (that actress looks older), they missed the desert storm, Saphira didnt just bcome a full grown dragon when she could fly, Eragon didnt get captured, they didnt even MENTION the nyota Saphire, Eragon being injured in the begining of the book, and ALOT of other things
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
It doesn't mean that the movie must be completely imitated kwa the book. The book has a different story plus an added scenes. And the movie have been summarized so that the movie was not too long.
Pauline_15 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
Lizijana said:
If wewe haven't read book - read it, it really worths that (except wewe don't wanna be disappointed in movie).
Well, I don't hate the movie, it's a nice family movie. However, if I look at it as a person, who has read that book, then I hate this movie (reasons are mentioned in other answers). The Eragon story could have become an epic movie, which would rival Lord of Rings au even Harry Potter in popularity, if Eragon story had been created kwa professionals. Well... but it didn't happen and movie makers fooled themselves - they created a movie which one must be continued, but it can't be because in the Eragon movie they changed the whole story too much.
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
darkfeather said:
I don't know about everyone else but I used to like the movie until I read the book and the two are just so different to me that its almost like they are two completely different stories. To me I think the book is better and the movie changed so many things that it isn't very good.
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
Aqua_Rose said:
I could go on for hours moaning about that movie.

The Eragon movie is a disgrace to the book. Sure, it's probably a good film on its own, but if you've read the book first it doesn't take long to realise what a poor translation from paper to film it is. There are so many differences betweent the book and the film it's practically a different story, and the movie leaves no room for a sequel that would be anything like Eldest, in which the Ra'zac finally die, and yet if I remember correctly the Ra'zac die in the movie of Eragon.

It would take ages to orodha all the differences between the book and the film, but I'll leave it at this: the film is definitely not true to the book at all. I hope this majibu your swali :)
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
dragon-lord said:
WHAT?????i have read all vitabu and i upendo both vitabu and the movie i think the movie was realy cool and it was made realy good i realy want them to make an eldest movie too
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
Eaor said:
The Main reason for me to hate the film is that Saphira who is a really strong and impressive Character in the book has no real character. She is just some animal that does what Eragon sayes. In the book she "stands up to him" and is really smart and is very clever. Also in the film the story is not really fluent. Big parts are not fitting together.
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
MikuHatsuneMiku said:
Personally, I hated the movie! It was nothing like the book, which was so awesome, but the movie changed its awesomeness!
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
bbc_4_ever said:
This contains spoilers,

The reason why we dislike the movie is because...
Eragon is suppose to be a brunette with brown (or grey) eyes.
Araya is suppose to have black hair and green eyes.
The Ra'zak are suppose to mysterious hooded figures with knees that bend the opposite ways than human knees, and then they have beaks.
wewe never see Eragon's dreams.
When Murtagh joins the battle he is not in the middle of the battle, he comes out of his cell in the beginning, on Ajihads orders.
Murtagh's cell is luxurious, he has everything he wants like, good food, and any book he wants to read.
Gabltorix and Srewiken never onyesha up in book one.
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
saphira1897 said:
if wewe read the book youll understand the movie left out soo much first of eragon was training for about a mwaka before brom died and even then months went kwa before the varden apered and then again what about the witch child elva he cursed instead of bleesed
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
mangaman222 said:
because its bad

select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
next question »