jibu swali hili

Heroes Swali

Can someone explain to me why there are three seperate sylars in the new season??

 haddy posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
next question »

Heroes Majibu

SamWinchester said:
Because the one Sylar is a haluzination from Matt. and the other Sylar was Nathan and he was real
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
this s what i see so far.. mind of sylar in matts head, real sylar morphed into nathan and finally a third sylar who everyone can see who has amnesia and is at the carnival.... thats what i dont get, three of them??
haddy posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
There's isn't a 'third Sylar'. The Sylar with amnesia at the carnival etc is the real Sylar who thought he was Nathan. Two Sylars. The one who was brainwashed into believing he was Nathan Petrelli who now realizes he isn't and has amnesia, and the one trapped in Matt Parkmans mind messing around with his life.
Cameron10 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
That makes sense now... i was just wondering about the new one coming from the ground but i get it nows thanks
haddy posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
hansolow2000 said:
Actually, everyone is wrong; nothing makes sense. I guess we'll just have to wait and see what spin the producers put on the story to have it make sense.

There should only be two physical Sylars (which there are), but the two that we're seeing now aren't consistent with what happened. The original Sylar was brainwashed kwa Matt and turned into Nathan using his morphing ability. That's why we now see the current Nathan struggling between himself and Sylar; that part makes sense. What doesn't make sense is the other Sylar coming out of the ground!!!

The Sylar that everyone (Peter, Claire, HRG, Angela, Matt) burned/buried at the end of last season was actually the body of the shape-shifter who died while in Sylar form/posing as Sylar. He was pretending to be Sylar when Denko and the real Sylar were hunting him. They figured him out and killed him. So when HRG, Matt and Angela tried to fool the others into thinking Sylar was killed, they used the shape-shifter's body, which was still in Sylar form, for the "funeral". That said, if anything, the Sylar that came out of the ground should be the original shape-shifter guy, NOT Nathan Petrelli! Nathan died when Sylar slit his throat. And since Nathan never had shape-shifting abilites, it doesn't make sense that the out-of-the-ground would Sylar think that he's Nathan; Nathan is dead. Again, the out-of-ground Sylar should, if anything, be the original shape-shifter.

That's where it doesn't add up and they lose. But like I alisema before, the writers will probably put a spin on it to jar everything line up in the end.
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
It isnt the shapeshifter who came out of the ground its Nathan/Sylar who came out of the ground he got killed kwa an assasin hired kwa that woman and buried
Sylarfan posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
Uhhh, yes it is the shape-shifter that came out of the ground. At the end of season 3, Nathan and Sylar fought in the hotel room and Syalar slit Nathan's throat. That's when Nathan died. Then Matt came in and brainwashed Sylar into thinking he was Nathan-Sylar shapeshifts and turns into Nathan. When Angel Petrelli asks "how are we going to pull this off", HRG says, "don't worry, I have a body back at the lab that we can use" (the original shape-shifter's body who died while in Sylar form). That's who got buried at the end of season 3: the shape-shifter who looks like Sylar, not Nathan. We never saw what became of Nathan's body. And because Nathan never had shape-shifting abilities, we can't assume that he morphed into Syalr before being buried...
hansolow2000 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
There was the Syalar body (really a shapshifter) that was buried to fake Syalars death. Then theres Syalar's real body that Matt forced Nathan's thoughts into and at the same time forced Syalar out of. This person now thinks he's Nathan. (though in hivi karibuni episodes he finds out the truth and wewe see what happened to nathans body) In the mean time Syalar's mind got stuck in Matts mind.
Jacara posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
i understand that part. the swali is, however, why is the Sylar coming out of the ground thinking that he's nathan???? The shape-shifter is who really came out of the ground...
hansolow2000 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
next question »