I loved her and felt so bad for her. I was hoping she would change after Regina gave her a second chance. I'm really liking Rumple a lot less right now for killing her and lying to Belle. This is also making me like Rumple and Belle as a couple much less.

The fear on her face before he did it was horrible. He is so nasty. Of course he is grieving but has he just stopped loving Belle, forgot he made a promise to her? And to think I was liking him. No character development there, not like Regina. At least she's actually changed.

WTH Rumple!!!!

I never though I would pick this one considering my hate for Zelena's character . Since she's powerless I really don't care what's happening to her even though I would like her to take Regina's second chance. I trully hated what Rumple did . WTF does he think that Belle will like this ?! This is the way to prove her his love ????! quite the opposite I'd say ,he treated Belle like he didn't care at all and yes Zelena killed Neal and I freaking wanted to punch her for that & she also treated Rumple as a pet but keep killing people isn't a solution ( wise Regina said it too ) . If Rumple reenacted that cra*py thing Zelena wanted to achieve then congrats Ms.Gold you just ruined everything .
Even though I'm not sure if Zelena's really gone ?!

And for many reasons

1st/ I love Zelena and I got so addicted to her character, she's my favorite after Regina and Cora

2nd/ Zelena wasn’t born evil or envious, she became that way because she had a shitty life she had in Oz, technically these are similar issues that made Regina, Rumple and Hook but they got I don't know how many second chances to redeem themselves and become better, and Zelena definitely deserved that too

3rd/ Zelena is last person that’s blood-related to Regina, and Regina deserves to have a sister, she needs her and Zelena needs Regina too, and I was so rooting for a beautiful sisterly relationship between those two

4th/ I know I'm not a Rumbelle shipper but I found killing Zelena was so unfair to Belle, Belle is a very good girl and so truly in love with Rumple, she's always stood by him, believed him and stood by his side, but what did he do to her ? Nothing ! He's always been selfish, Belle trusted him but he betrayed her trust as he always had. He doesn't deserve her

5th/ People are happy that Zelena died because she's the one who killed Neal. Sorry but am I the only one who doesn't find Zelena responsible (or completely responsible) for Neal's death ?! I know she didn't tell him that the price of the magic he did to resurrect his father was him dying but Belle did warn Neal then that all magic comes with a price and of course Neal wasn't stupid he definitely knew that this kind of magic like resurrecting the dead was going to cost him a lot but Neal was so willing to pay it

6th/ You don't understand but I SO FREAKING LOVED ZELENA !! And I'm really really tired of watching my favorite characters die :"( (Whether in OUAT or in other tv shows or movies)

Sometimes I feel like watching this show was the worst mistake of my miserable fangirl life

She actually moved into my top five for one...
I actually really liked Zelena, she was so awesome and I was totally psyched to see Gina give her a second chance as I thought Gina would kill her. I was happy to see her alive and happy to see her gain the possibility for a second try and then low and behold Rumps takes it.

To go with that, a good number of people will probably point their finger at Regina for 1.) killing Zelena and 2.) casting another curse *CoughLeroyCough*. Because it seems that no matter how much good she does, they always hate on her anyhow. Not to mention, she wasn't with Emma, Hook, Snow, and David when it happened. Hopefully this time they'll have the sense to accuse the one who wanted to kill Zelena in the first place and not the one who saved her from that man.

For thirds, Gina was finally happy and he screwed that one up...again. Was it not bad enough that he manipulated her into casting the last curse. That he had caused her to feel such misery and hopelessness the last time. And oh look, she finally made herself happy again finally started to undo some of that damage he'd done. And then he indirectly takes away her chance at a happy life again.

And if I gather right from the previews--she's the evil queen again. Which is a terrible shame after all that amazing character development. He basically reset all she worked for. All the effort she put into changing herself. I mean for freaks sake I'd love to tell those people with double standards to tell me that Rumple is a better person and deserves a second shot more than Gina now!

For fourths, everyone else was happy as well. Like there was not one person who didn't seem happy that Zelena was safely locked away and that the baby was safe. Emma was smiling, Hook, Henry. Everyone. And now it's over. Short lived.

Fourth, the baby. That poor baby. Snow's gonna lose another. The Charmings thought they'd have another shot at raising a baby from the start. But nope, not even. And from the looks of it, that baby just poofs out of existence.

Fifthly, Belle trusted him. What the heck was that? I was never really fond of Rumbelle. I found it to be borderline abusive verbally and physically. But I didn't hate it, I tolerated it. I just can't anymore--that was like the last straw. She trusted him, and it wasn't just any trust it was like, he offered her a really big piece of him as a gift for trusting him so...and it wasn't even real. No, she trusted him not to go after Zelena, he promised he wouldn't, he did. He used that marriage proposal to deceive her. And I really do hope she finds out.

Sixth Gina Was finally happy!!!

Seventh, 99% sure that Neal wouldn't have wanted him to extract vengeance like that, as he was the one who kept telling him to change. Throughout his whole life Neal was trying to cope with the bad things his father had done. Throughout all of season two he was trying to get his dad to stop. And in season 3 he finally got him to and was really proud 'you really have changed'. And then he dies, and Rumple picks the habit back up.

And also, are we not going to discuss that even Rumps was opposed to her curse succeeding. Yet he's the one to enact it. Like really, he's to smug to realize that he just unleashed the very thing his son died to prevent.

I seriously had just moved him out of my bottom five characters--guess who's back in it?

The only two things I liked about it is that it keeps the plot moving (and that I can no say with certainty that Gina is more morally correct when arguing with a hater) and the fact that Emma can't take Henry back to NYC.

@BellalLovett Totally agree.

I love Neal but I kind of think he knew he would die. I think he wanted to die for his father, Zelena was only telling him how to do it. So I don't think the fault entirely lies on Zelena's side. I loved her even after she kills Neal so that's probably true, otherwise I'd hate her. Zanhar what is your actual top 5 now, it keeps changing? ;P ^

Yeah;

1. Gina
2. Zelena
3. Tink
4. Cora
5. Ruby

Never stays the same.
Zelena is the first character to screw with my favorite character and not be in the bottom five. And the first and last who will probably make it into the top 5.

Ah, cool, I like that list. I love Zelena as much as everyone in my top 10 but I just can't remove anyone I love them all too much! :P ^

^^ That's not really true. I see Cora on that list. Aside from Rumple she probably had the biggest hand in screwing up Gina's life

I think Zanhar1 meant trying to kill Regina or something, like what Zelena was trying to do to her. ^

Actually she's right, I was talking physical and verbal--mostly physical though (like if Zelena were to kill Gina she'd hit rock bottom). But yeah, I shouldn't have said first when I was thinking 'one of the first' so that was poor wording. However Zelena is the first person to actually try to kill my favorite that is on the list--I know Cora considered, but she went back on it.

I loved her, what the heck Rumple

Right.

I never cared for Zelena. She was a rather shallow character, in my opinion, and I never saw anything in her that I could like about her except for when she was trying to be good. But then the moment she felt like she wasn't at the center of attention of the other witches, she became bitter and jealous. I just got tired of it.

What I didn't like about her being killed was the fact that:

A) I was really hoping to see some sisterly bond develop between Regina and Zelena. I would have loved to see them interact without trying to kill each other. It would have been the best sister relationship! I could totally see them shopping and pulling pranks on other people with their magic. It would have been awesome.

B) Rumple deceived and manipulated Belle. I know it's not the first time, but come on! They're going to know Zelena was killed and either they will figure out that it was Rumple, and then Belle will leave him, or he'll try to blame it on Regina. Which if he does that, the truth always comes out, which means Belle will discover that he killed Zelena then tried to lie about that as well, placing the blame on someone else, and then she'll leave him. Either way, I don't think Belle will tolerate what Rumple just did and she'll leave him because it's going to be the straw that broke the camel's back (understandable, he manipulated her and broke her trust) and then Rumple is going to whine and moan about how he made a mistake. Every time there's some kind of development with him, they drag him two steps back. Maybe it's part of the plan. I don't know. But it's irritating.

C) Zelena's a likable character when she's not being self-centered and jealous. I would have really liked to see them explore that part of her personality.

That's another good point; I wanted to see more Gina and Zelena sisterhood.

"Sometimes I feel like watching this show was the worst mistake of my miserable fangirl life"
Yeah me too @ BellaLovett! Me too!

I love Mr.Gold and everything but a big part of me just rages that Rumple did this. I know he is is a big baddie, but I really feel sick to my stomach...why does he have to have his hands on everything?!
I believe Zelena wanted that second chance and she was going to take it eventually but NO Rumple had to show up and ruin everything under the name of the son he has justified all his other deeds too.
Way to go Rumple, Bae would be so proud of you for hiding behind the Dark One's magic once AGAIN! Bravo!
I have never been more disappointed by a TV show before till the Kansas episode. You have that wonderful scene of Rumple proposing to Belle, only to snatch it back by having him kill Zelena?!
Dude, did you really proposed while holding a fake dagger?!
Now that was RUDE & NASTY! Poor Belle! To betray her trust DURING the proposal!

"I just can't anymore" too @ zanhar1 too! "--that was like the last straw." indeed!!!!!!
I can't wait for when Belle finds out & shit hits the fan! :P LoL

Plus I will certainly be missing the lost opportunity of Regina knowing her sister as well!!!!!

I want Zelena back! I was really starting to love her actually...

Right, can't wait 'til she finds out.

^ I am crossing my fingers for season 4 now....