her beginnings with fashion, cool Brucas scenes, she had a really good storyline for season 3, so definitely 3 is best for her.

+ 6 :)

I always loved her but it was in season 5 that she became my favorite!
I loved her also in seasons 2-3-4 very very very much but then I'd prefer Hales :D

Hate her in S1 and dislike her in the first episodes of S4 (but after 4x16 I love her) .
S5 is her best ,when I really loved her <33

I only don't like her in season 1 and 4. In season 1, I really didn't like Brooke, I would see her as a bitch. In season 4, she was really mean to everyone and mostly Lucas and Peyton. The only part I loved her in that season was when she started dating Chase.
I picked season 2 because that's when I felt for Brooke and she become my second favorite after Peyton. I really get to know her and understand her. She was great in all the other seasons, I adored her in season 5. When Peyton and Lucas left so seasons 7-9 she really became my favorite <3

I love Brooke in season 5, I feel like we saw her mature and become this great person but we still saw a little bit of her childish/bubbly side. It was a good mix. I also really like her in season 6. I'm not a huge fan of her in any other season.

By miles & miles!

Didn't like her much in season 1 and season 4. But she changed so much in S5/S6 and I loved her. Personally I don't like what they did to her character in the following seasons.

She was at her best, I really loved her <3