My first choice for Melanie is Odette.I think she's the one that looks like Mel's description the most. You might say she's skinny but if she gains a few more weights, she'll be the best.

Grrr, i'm really not sold on Odette at all! I much prefer the other suggestion made of Hannah Taylor Gordon for the part of Mel...seems to fit a lot better, at least in my head.

Hannah Taylor Gordon looks nothing like Mel :(

I totally disagree 'kuncuyung'....for me, Hannah is exaaaactly how I pictured Melanie! How exactly does Odette look more like her?? Anways, the whole point of fiction is that it's completely subjective. My Mel won't look anything like another persons Mel. That's why the most important thing is that they cast an incredible actress for the role!

I think she has a bit of innocence but is still strong looking. Its like she has a bit of Wanda and Melanie in her. I like it!

she is better than all! especially Hannah Taylor Gordon and Sophia Bush

Looks like people who say yes are growing in number :) Nice :)))

I think Bush would make a better Mel, but I would also be really happy if Yustman got the role.