Emily Sawyer

Four-year-old Emily Sawyer was last seen on April 1, 1988 in Toledo, Ohio. She is believed to be with her mom, Carol Sinkey Sawyer, who didn't have custody of her at the time.

Carol and her ex-husband, Daniel Sawyer got divorced in 1985 and Daniel got remarried. She made allegations that Daniel molested Emily, but an investigation turned up no evidence that Emily had been abused.

Emily and Carol disappeared the day before the judge was supposed to give Daniel custody of Emily. Emily spent Easter with Carol. When Daniel went to pick her up, they were gone.

Daniel later sued Carol's parents, John and Marian Sinkey, claiming that they helped hide Emily and know where she is, but they denied the claims and Daniel lost the lawsuit when it came to trial. 

Emily and Carol may be being assisted by an organization called Children of the Underground that help hide women and kids who claim to be abused. The leader of the organization, Faye Yager admitted to helping Emily and Carol, and is also revealed to have helped conceal other kids.

As of 2023, Emily remains missing.