Debate
What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)
Debate Being racist automatically makes a person bad through and through;
18 fans picked: |
Disagree
|
|||
Agree
|
|
Make your pick! | next poll >> |
You can be uncomfortable without being a dick about it, like in Z's example. You can't help the way you feel, but you can help the way you treat people.
but people can be good in many ways....
if they do more good than bad then they are good people
racism is not good it is a terrible ugly trait, i say this as a human who has faced racism....
... but people can do many good things even if they be racist....
it is not a good thing but it is not poisonous to a whole person if they are good about it and not harming others based on the races they have
@Riku I think your link is broken.
I think Zanhar's friend is a bad person. Maybe not for having that feeling, no one can really control how they feel. But for trying to wave it away and pretend that it isn't problematic and something that needs to be addressed.
Speaking generally a person with this view in a hiring position could be a bit more damaging. As this person is directly impacting another. Fear is powerful and it's definitely an issue with an interviewing job. But I still don't think that it makes them 100% bad. Espically if they realize that they have this unconscious biases and aim to fix them. I simply think that a person is more than one ugly trait. And that if they can keep that trait in check (though changing it would be better) that it isn't quite as harmful. Granted there are always exceptions and specifications as you examplified above.
I'm also going to say (in defense of said friend) that he/she isn't waving it off that's why he/she asked me in the first place. 40 years into his/her view, growing up with a racist mom, he/she is starting to question those beliefs. If that makes sense. I suppose I should have added that in my first comment but I wanted to get to the point.
Murderers: "not being a murderer" doesn't mean you're a good person. But you're still a bad person if you are a murderer.
Ergo Nazis, rapists, lawyers.
So I don't think the negative has much bearing on this question. "Not being racist" is not really an indicator of how bad/good you are - there are many other more important deciding factors, like you said. However, being racist is an important deciding factor. I would say one of the most important ones.
Not necessarily decisive. But a significant and compelling indication. And I agree with Aang: being racist yet "trying to wave it away and pretend that it isn't problematic and something that needs to be addressed" is more important than the feeling itself. And it depends on circumstances: is this person racist because they've been brought up like that in some backwater with no exposure to opposing ideas and actual facts? Or is this person in a metropolitan place, in contact with people of other races, and have they been exposed to the statistics and facts of the matter, yet still they think other races are inferior? If it's the latter, I'd find it hard to regard them as a good person.
ingia au ujiunge na fanpop ili kuongeza maoni yako