jibu swali hili

Harry Potter dhidi ya Twilight Swali

For Twihards and Antis!!!

This is sort of weird and random. But...

...for Twihards: orodha 10-20 reasons why Harry Potter is better...

...and for Antis: orodha 10-20 reasons why Twilight is better...

Note: For Twihards: Reasons like "Edward is HOT!" are invalid. For Antis: Reasons like "Twilight makes a good bonfire/toilet paper" are invalid (even if it's true).

I'll become a shabiki and give a heshima to whoever lists zaidi than 10 reasons...

GOOD LUCK!!!
 For Twihards and Antis!!!
*
Ginny, this is hard. But I upendo the pic!
AprilCandy42 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
^ Which face? I think Robe's is stupider.
ToyletGnome posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
^ Rob's face of course. We laughed so damn hard at it in ninth grade, lol.
Aquilia posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
 Slytherclaw143 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
next question »

Harry Potter dhidi ya Twilight Majibu

LoopyLuna96 said:
Twilight:
1. It can be romantic.
2. It's good entertainment.
3. The characters are relatable.
4. Something to talk about.
5. It can be fun.
6. Some characters seem nicer than Harry Potter ones (eg, Alice and Voldemort)
7. It's educational.
8. It's got zaidi teen girls into reading.
9. It teaches wewe that upendo is eternal.
10. upendo can be found anywhere.

That was SO hard.
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
Wow. You're very , VERY smart.
kwlski4ever posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
Thank you. It was very hard after number three!
LoopyLuna96 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
I like the number 8. :)
mitchie19 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
XDRoseLuvsHP said:
1. Twilight has sparked the interest of uandishi in teenage girls everywhere.
2. Twilight has sparked the interest of kusoma in teenage girls everywhere.
3. Twilight has made Forks, Washington rich.
4. I read that Twilight helped a girl see that her boyfriend was abusive, and she dumped him because she didn't want to end up like Bella.
5. I learned a new word: chagrin.
6. There were a couple of characters I didn't mind. There was Seth and Leah.
7. It gives Wanyonya damu an original twist (sparkling).
8. In New Moon, the Volturi were pretty cool (they were completely and utterly ruined in Breaking Dawn, but that's beside the point).
9. Dakota Fanning is in the movie.
10. Hot Topic made a considerable profit off of Twilight merchandise.

Sheesh, this was hard. I was trying to be honest and uninsulting in my points. I hope I succeeded :P

But Harry Potter is still better :)
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
Lol, agreed. Hary Potter Rules!
TeamSiriusBlack posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
HP forever! lol
volleyblue13 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
MadamOcta13 said:
Twilight:

1. It brings daughters closer to their mothers.
2. It inspires debate.
3. It tells the epic tale of a girl who found someone who makes her feel special.
4. It shows wewe don't have to be perfect to be loved.
5. The characters are attractive.
6. It has suspense and danger.
7. It shows young girls how to deal with life-like situations.
8. It revived the upendo for *cringes* vampires.
9. It inspired other authors to write upendo stories about vampires.
10. It shows how strong, wonderful, and difficult upendo can be.



(I wanted to shoot myself for uandishi number 8; I'm ashamed. I'm sorry Bram Stoker! I'm sorry Prince Vlad The Impaler! *sobs*)
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
those are good reasons too! good job! ;) that must have taken so long!
HuddyJoy0524 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
tymple said:
harry potter

1 many people loved harry potter first
2 harry potter sinema have better actors like david tennant
3 it is higher than a forth grade level
4 takes me the same amount to read one(1 week)as it does to read all the twilight books
5 harry potter has zaidi fans
6 jk rowling is a better author
7 harry potter has Wanyonya damu mtu-bweha AND WISARDS
8 harry potter is actual litarary magic
9 the covers actualy mach the story
10 hermiony is a better role modle than bella,edward ect.
11 the weaslys represent wewe dont need money to be happy
12 twillight is repeditive
13 twillight is realy realy mushy
14 harry potter is less grusum wont give little kids nightmares
15 harry potter mashabiki are zaidi devoted
16 twilliht has aliiba some stuff from harry potter
17 stephonie myer has only made one good book(the host)
18 has zaidi vitabu
19 harry potter vitabu have been around longer
20 the vitabu actualy make sense

ha i made it to 20!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
....are wewe sure your a twilight shabiki lol
Free_Spirit posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
I actually thought the Host was really boring. After kusoma the first chapter of it, I was bored, confused and tired.
ABDCFan- posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
ps i read the qeustion wrong im not a twitard
tymple posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
Free_Spirit said:
Twilight
1. It is a page turner
2. A new concpet on vampires
3. Got girls reading
4. A way to make friends-something to discuss-
5. has taught girls ne words
6. Gave one woman the oppurtunity to fulfill her dream
7. Girls have started writing
8. MAde robert patterson and Krsiten stewart famous
9. Has brought up some fabulous debates
10. That if wewe take your girlfriend nyumbani your family will upendo her so much they'd upendo to eat her up
11.That girls don't have to wear dresses and shovel make up on themselves to be pretty au to get a boyfriend
12. Personality outshines looks
ummm thats all i can think of :)
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
Ginny (Slytherclaw143) told me to give wewe a heshima for uandishi zaidi than 10 things. WOO
AprilCandy42 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
Yayyy ;)
Free_Spirit posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
MrsJonasLautner said:
Do wewe notice that zaidi Harry Potter mashabiki are saying nice stuff about Twilight than Twilight mashabiki are about Harry Potter. HA! That's becuase wewe can't find any good reasons about HP! GO TWILIGHT!
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
I think it's because we're big enough people to admit that there are good things about it. Twi-hards aren't intelligant enough most of the time.GO HARRY POTTER!
LoopyLuna96 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
I think wewe should look at the 1000 reasons why Harry Potter is better than Twilight forum. wewe will find nearly 3000 reasons why Harry Potter owns Twilight. Than go to the 1000 reasons Twilight is better than Harry Potter forum, and wewe will find about 5. And none of them are valid.
PotterForever posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
@Mrs.JonasLautner: Dude... no... just, no...
GemonkDruid posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
top-star said:
wewe don't need reasons.you are favouring the antis from the start which makes it an invalid question
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
1. This is a debate, wewe do need reasons.
ToyletGnome posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
2. There was no favouritism. It's still a valid question.
ToyletGnome posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
They're seeking favoritism becoz they CAN'T find reasons, XDRoseLuvsHP . top-star, wewe need reasons to like something au hate something, and without reasons, the whole feeling is invalid. for example i hate twilight because it makes no sense to me and it's boring. say the same about HP. i'd like to hear it.
vskparaimer posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
ToyletGnome said:
I've found it completely impossible to write even 5 reasons explaining why Twilight is better. The reason is that I can pull together some weak-ass reasons explaining why it's good, but I know Harry Potter is better at it.

eg. Twilight has romance - Harry Potter's romance is zaidi realistic and much healthier.
Twilight inspires teens to read - Harry Potter inspires people of all ages to read good quality literature.
In Twilight, the use of 1st person PoV helps us get to know Bella in zaidi detail - In Harry Potter, the use of 3rd person limited PoV lets us get to know all the characters much better than any of the characters in Twilight, as most of them are under-developed stereotypes, AND we don't have to put up with Bella's incessant whining and constant descriptions of Edward's incredible beauty.

See what I mean? The only time I could ever think of a point where Twilight actually won, it was in the field of "promotes bad values."
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
Haha, I completely agree with you. But I honestly tried. I could barely think of reasons why Twilight was remotely decent even. But better? Well, I did try.
XDRoseLuvsHP posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
I was trying too, but 30 mins later... nothing, so I gave up.
ToyletGnome posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
LOL!
vskparaimer posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
mitchie19 said:
TwiHard speaking:

>Harry Potter is better because some people don't like Wanyonya damu they prefer Wizards.

>It attracts the readers. While Twilight only attracts women. (Peace. I still upendo Twilight)

>The Villains are zaidi dangerous than Twilight.
Lord Voldemort for example.

>They say, Harry Potter is zaidi original?

I don't know what else.

-Some of them i got from other websites-)

:)peace.

I.L.T.
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
ravynflyte said:
Twilight: I AM an Anti, but I'm going to try this. :) I'm trying for 15, just because I feel like a good challenge right now.

1. Its nice that everyone has a happy ending in the book. Its a nice 'refresher' from all of the emo/depressing vitabu that I've been kusoma lately.
2. It made Stephenie Meyer a very happy woman. At least, I hope she's happy. :) She's rich, famous and she has a good-sized fanbase. I can't guarantee that it'll last though.
3. Robert Pattison, Kristen Stewart, and Taylor Lautner now all have many fans. I'm pretty sure that being in Twilight got them a lot of attention.
4. The romance in Twilight is zaidi in-your-face-obvious than Harry Potter.
5. The covers look cool. All black and emo-y. :D
6. I'm not sure about this, but I'm guessing that Forks, Washington has a lot zaidi tourists coming its way now. Ehehe. XD
7. It inspired many zaidi vampire stories. (Although Vampire Diaries came first...)
8. Hot Topic is earning mountains of money from the sale of Twilight clothes. XD
9. 13-18 mwaka old girls (Sorry, but I personally think that anyone who hasn't taken Family Life Education should NOT read Twilight. Especially Breaking Dawn.) have stuff to talk about in school/wherever.
10. Pale people can now be considered extremely attractive. Honestly, I don't like it, but its better than fake-tanning.
11. Uhh... Blue-eyed blondes are no longer considered "in" if you're a Twilighter? What I mean, is that almost everyone is dark-haired and dark-eyed. :D Break the stereotype people!
12. Spiky, messy hair is "in" for guys? Like Edward's hair? (Sorry. XD I'm kinda running out of ideas.)

Dang. Sorry. >.< I can't really think of anything else right now. Hope it was fair enough! :D
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
Oh yes, Forks has hundreds of thousands of tourists now. Of course that's all good and well if wewe want rabid twitards invading your town, which most of them don't. I feel really sorry for the guy who let the filmmakers use his house as Bella and Charlie's in the movie... Yikes!
ToyletGnome posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
vskparaimer said:
Okay *deep breath* gonna try...

Twilight.

1) Has nice monochromatic covers that look attractive on a shelf.
2) Stuff to talk about.
3) Robert Pattinson to faint for. (duh)
4) Jamie Campbell Bower, heard he's gonna play in the movie. and i luv him since Sweeney Todd!
5) Kristen and Rob became a couple. If they're happy together, it's plus for Twilight.
6) It made people integrate. Not that HP didn't.
7) Dakota Fanning!
8) Paramore played.
9) Umm... it made teens read a lot (these are nice big books)? teen girls, actually?
10) It made people invent names (Twi-hard au Twitlight would never get in common use if not that.
11) It has proven some novels shouldn't be over 100 sites long.
12) It made Stephenie Meyer (and the actors from the movies) very rich.
13) It made some people write. Never mind parodies and fanfics. it simply made them zaidi creative then before... some of them. Twilight didn't really change my creativity.
14) Er... some of us became interested in *vampires* and/or mtu-bweha in culture and literature.
15) ... *bursts in tears* it made people like me and other Antis think of these reasons. See? No Twilight, no HP/Twilight spot, no debate.

Okay, that makes 15, folks. for me, it's not better, but these make it ... edible. period.
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
ooh apparently their relationship is now being faked!
FredWRules posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
yay. found that out too. that what, Rob P alisema that it's just for the movie au what. that's what i read. s
vskparaimer posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
RavenclawPride said:
HP shabiki here... going for 20 reasons.

1. It's a vampire romance novel. I upendo that genre, so immediate up for me.

2. It has interesting characters, like Carlisle and Rosalie.

3. wewe can tell that the Cullens and Wolfpack have a close bond.

4. OK, I'll give Twilight the hot guys factor ( Not talking about R-Pattz. )

5. It is a page turner.

6. The suspense in it is really good. There is little suspense, but it is good.

7. wewe can tell that Edward is devoted to Bella, and vice-versa.

8. wewe gotta admit the Cullens have some pretty cool abilities. And they don't need a wand to activate these abilities.

9. Bella gave Renesmee the chance to live, even though it might mean losing her life.

10. It has lovable characters, like Seth and Alice.

11. It gives wewe an in-depth experience on what Bella's surroundings are like.

12. It captivates readers the first time around.

13. It encouraged zaidi teenage girls to read.

14. It had promise. It could've turned out to be a great book.

15. It has a large and devoted fanbase, just like HP.

16. There's some pretty cool sanaa ya shabiki for Twilight. I found that out when I was a Twilighter.

17. It's inspired some people to write. My Marafiki appreciate literature and uandishi more, thanks to Twilight.

18. It's easier to tell how Bella feels, because it is in first person.

19. It is easier to put readers in that place, because Forks is a real town.

20. People can relate to some of Bella's experiences, like going to school.


Whew, that was harder than expected.
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
HecateA said:
O-kay, here I go.

1 It reminds everybody that dreams are possible (Meyer got rich and fameous)
2 It's gotten teen girls reading
3 I bet some bookstores got a lot zaidi business when Twilight came out
4 The characters are relatable
5 Its entertaining (for some antis, like me, first time ou read it its pretty good)
6 Some find it romantic
7 It's aliyopewa us something to talk about
8 Some of the actors I'd never heard of, but now I go "hey, that's the chick in Twilight..." so fame for the actors
9 It makes a lot of people smile every time they open the book (HP too, but whatev)
10 The merchandise is good for economy?
11 A lot of other vampire series/books got publicity because of Twilight
12 Buffy made a comeback! (had to put it, but I still gave zaidi then 10 valid ones)

wewe owe me a heshima :D
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
Karipoof said:
Um I'm a shabiki of both, but I like Twilight zaidi so I'm going to do hp here.

1. The story has a good plot.
2. It is funny.
3. It is a lovely chanzo of entertainment.
4. The characters are cool.
5. The cast do a better job, as far as sinema are concerned. (yes I'll admit that the characters Edward and Bella are portrayed horribly)
6. It is a book that children of any age can read.
7. It is a book that keeps people engrossed. (I'm doing this honestly so I'll admit that two of my Marafiki and my sister for that matter got bored after kusoma Twilight.........my sister was bored after kusoma until page five of Twilight)
8. Harry Potter has magic, something I love.
9. Most mashabiki are interested in the vitabu and sinema equally. Some Twilight mashabiki like the vitabu more, some like the sinema more.
10. Harry Potter's villains were zaidi evil than Twilight's.

There. I'm done. This wasn't so bad. Oh but I still like Twilight more.

select as best answer
 Um I'm a shabiki of both, but I like Twilight zaidi so I'm going to do hp here. 1. The story has a good plot. 2. It is funny. 3. It is a lovely chanzo of entertainment. 4. The characters are cool. 5. The cast do a better job, as far as sinema are concerned. (yes I'll admit that the characters Edward and Bella are portrayed horribly) 6. It is a book that children of any age can read. 7. It is a book that keeps people engrossed. (I'm doing this honestly so I'll admit that two of my Marafiki and my sister for that matter got bored after kusoma Twilight.........my sister was bored after kusoma until page five of Twilight) 8. Harry Potter has magic, something I love. 9. Most mashabiki are interested in the vitabu and sinema equally. Some Twilight mashabiki like the vitabu more, some like the sinema more. 10. Harry Potter's villains were zaidi evil than Twilight's. There. I'm done. This wasn't so bad. Oh but I still like Twilight more.
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
elliehedgehog said:
this is gonna be hard but...

twilight
1:the names of the character are cool
2:same with the book names
3:the covers are nice
4:it got me into vampiers again (if u can call them that)
5:bella rly cares for edward and the other way round
6:some of the actors i have never heard of before now i know them
7:paramore did some of the songs
8:leave out all the rest kwa linkin park was on the movie credits
9:robert and kristen are dateing bec of it
and
10:the cullens house looks nice

MAN that was hard but im done

HARRY POTTER FOREVER

that took 15 mins to type O_O

select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
HannahLupin said:
i'm a harry potter fan, so i guess i have to do toilet.. er, twilight.

1) it got teenage girls to read more. now when i sign onto facebook, and creep a person's books, it'll say something like "i dnt red much, but i luv twilite!!"

2)you can easily relate to bella.. to an extent.

3)their shape shifter wannabe mtu-bweha sound pretty sweet.

4) uh, it uses a lot of big words.

5) it shows that a family can stick together through anything.

6) bella's friendship with jacob is nice.

7) the upendo is so powerful that bella goes halfway across the world to stop edward from killing himself.

8)the soundtrack for the sinema has some alright bands (death cab for cutie, vampire weekend)

that's all i could think of. D: i'm going to go re-read all the harry potters to cleanse my mind.
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
next question »