If Haley and Sawyer are close why can't Peyton and Lydia be close?;)

I think if Peyton came back to take over RBR but Chris still stayed we would get some pretty funny and amazing scenes;)

Now, as for Karen's Cafe. I think I might be the only one but its always bugged me that Brooke and Haley were the one's to start Karen's Cafe, I personally think that Peyton has much more of a right to do that. *shrugs*

All sounds wonderful<3

^^ I don't want to upset you or anything, but what claim does Peyton really have to Karen's Cafe?? {I could understand if it was Tric} I don't mean anything rude by that, but Haley obviously spent tons of time there - she worked there! And we know that Karen loved Brooke, she took her in and then she let Brooke use the cafe as her store. So it wasn't at all surprising to me that Brooke & Haley would open the cafe together you know?

^No. I don't think it's rude. Tbh, out of all three girls I think Haley has the most right, but for me personally Brooke running it and naming it Karens cafe just seems random and out of place for me.

Now, as for Karen's Cafe. I think I might be the only one but its always bugged me that Brooke and Haley were the one's to start Karen's Cafe, I personally think that Peyton has much more of a right to do that. *shrugs*

Word. Glad I'm not the only one who feels this way. It's not so much that Brooke shouldn't be running Karen's cafe... it's just that it doesn't make much sense, and she truly has no real ties to the business. It simply kind of caught me off guard, and confused me when I first heard of Brooke's involvement.

Atleast if Paley did it together, it would be like a family business type of thing. After all, Peyton is Karen's daughter-in-law now. So it would be Haley re-opening the cafe that she grew up working at with Karen, and adding on new family members to help! I just think it would make much more sense, and be more meaningful that way. :)

but for me personally Brooke running it and naming it Karens cafe just seems random and out of place for me.

I understand that, i just always figured that they had Brooke name it Karen's Cafe out of tribute/respect towards Karen.

I LOVE CHRIS ♥♥

I agree with Holly though, to me I think Peyton has the least reason to open it I guess. Because Brooke also did work there as well in season 2, and like Holly said, Brooke most likely did it as a tribute!!! And to me, Brooke is still family to Karen, they just wouldn't be related, so it would still be a family business.

BUT to be honest, no one really has a BIG right to open the cafe, as the cafe was a big thing in ALL the core five's life, but I think if anyone should have helped Haley, it should have been Lucas !!n But again, just my opinion!! I think Brooke had every right as Haley did and as Peyton to open that cafe! :)

I STILL LOVE YOU KELLY AND MOOSHY :)

no one really has a BIG right to open the cafe, as the cafe was a big thing in ALL the core five's life, but I think if anyone should have helped Haley, it should have been Lucas !!

So agreed. Honestly, Brooke and Peyton have equal rights when it comes to Karen's cafe, there is no way Peyton did more for the cafe than Brooke, but Brooke did not do much either so... like everyone said, Brooke most likely just did it as a tribute to a place that had a huge impact on all of them. But if there are people who have MOST rights, it is definitely Haley and Lucas.

As for the question itself, I'd love to see Haley, Chris and Peyton handing out, sure it would have been something hilarious.