jibu swali hili

Harry Potter dhidi ya Twilight Swali

"Why Harry Potter is nothing for children"

Well, it´s called like this...

link

What do wewe think about that?
 Aquamarina posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
next question »

Harry Potter dhidi ya Twilight Majibu

VampiresRevenge said:
Old makala is old.

"It's difficult to imagine wanting to help your best friend defeat Voldemort when wewe know he'll be celebrating afterwards kwa casting 'Disapearro Clothesimo' on your sister."

"You might think this is harmless fantasy, until wewe realize that every young Harry Potter shabiki with a troubled nyumbani life spends his au her days waiting up for goblins to carry them off to a land where wizards don't come nyumbani drunk and yell at witches all night."

Ahahaha, again, this is why I upendo Cracked.

Oh, and I agree with the article.
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
The stupid thing about this makala is that Disappearro Clothesimo isn't a Harry Potter spell. Therefore Voldemort won't cast it. And the fact that I have a troubled life yet I don't wait for goblins to carry me off to the wizarding world. Also, another wrong thing is that, goblins DON'T carry wewe to the wizarding world. The Hogwarts Express does.
AprilCandy42 posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
Hahaha.
VampiresRevenge posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
Plotlynn17 said:
i think until the 4th book it's fine for younger children --but still their seeing worse on tv

oh and #3 bothered me-- wewe allowed to draw inspiration from history

most writers do borrow themes

Shakespeare's The tragedy of Julius Caesar

even twilight where wewe can find a lot of parallels to Romeo and Juliet
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
Is the fourth book fine for younger children, though? I mean, I read it when I was six and look how screwed-up I turned out!
ToyletGnome posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
XDRoseLuvsHP said:
Okay, I only read numbers three and one, but...

Three: Yeah, Voldemort is supposed to be very similar to Hitler. But did wewe notice that Voldemort is the BAD GUY? Voldemort isn't the hero; he's the main antagonist, and an extremely evil one at that. Just because we can feel bad for him because of his horrid childhood doesn't mean we think what he does is okay. Why do wewe think the whole story exists? Because they have to STOP Voldemort.

One: There's actually a very good reason Harry is sent nyumbani to the Dursleys every summer. If he weren't, he would be hunted down and killed kwa Voldemort quickly with no one there to help him. So would wewe rather Harry spend a few months of somewhat unpleasantness? au would wewe rather he gets himself murdered, then Voldemort succeeds in taking over the wizarding world and killing off all Muggle-borns like the Holocaust all over again? Make your pick.

Obviously, the people who wrote this makala haven't read the books. They've obviously only watched the movies, because even the least competent readers would understand the above points I've made.
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
*
I agree with what wewe said, but the makala isn't really supposed to be taken seriously. I mean, it's Cracked, haha. It was just supposed to be a funny look at why it wouldn't be good for kids. That site never does a serious article.
VampiresRevenge posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
*
You´re both right :) And another reason why Harry has to go back to the Dursleys every summer is explained in OotP. Dumbledore alisema there in the end that the upendo of Harrys mother who died for him protects him against Voldemort but only as long as he lives in one house with her sister.
Aquamarina posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita
EalasaidWooster said:
I can see what they're getting at, but I'm afraid I don't entirely agree with everything in it.

I agree that the book does have some themes in it that are inappropriate for children (death, racism, etc) but the whole point of the series is overcoming the inequalities and unpleasantness of life, and learning to be happy. :)

As a matter of fact, the scene in DH where Harry finds out he has to give himself up actually helped me overcome my fear of death. I would just re-read the passage and see how brave he was and I would feel better!!

It was....comforting. :)
select as best answer
posted zaidi ya mwaka mmoja uliopita 
next question »