|
Amy3422 said:
I can't maoni as to which has zaidi fans, but I believe that there are several reasons why Harry Potter would still be the better series: Twilight appeals to the masses because it's quite easy to read. It's light, entertaining and caters to a lot of the themes directed at adolescents. However, if wewe compare who is a shabiki of each series, there is a huge difference. (No offense to any intelligent Twilight fans.) In my experience most Twilight mashabiki read less widely and less challenging books. Many of them only like the series for hormonal reasons, as an embarrasing proportion of the series revolves around describing hot guys. (How many people hated New Moon, because there was no Edward?) As well, many people watch the sinema so that they can either drool over the male characters au make fun of the lousy script. (Even mashabiki of the book recognize how ridiculous it was.) Harry Potter, I find, is read kwa a much zaidi diverse group of people: children and adults, male and female etc., and I beilieve that it will last much longer. It is already tought in universities and the writting and story are genius. While Twilight has a relatively simple story, set in a pre-existing town; Harry Potter has an incredibly complex plot that is both unique (although it may be one of the better 'teen vampire' books, Twilight is still almost identical to many other series), and draws on a great deal of mythology and literature. (It is clear that the series is very well researched, while the mythology in Twilight is not.) There is significantly zaidi in the Harry Potter series: fantasy, adventure, mystery, and some realistic romance. It covers a lot zaidi different topics, zaidi time, zaidi detail, zaidi character development and therefore requires zaidi thought. Last of all there are the messages aliyopewa kwa the books. Harry Potter shows life and the magical situations in the book the way they are. Although it has some very admirable characters, it is honest about inaonyesha their flaws. For these characters, life is difficult but worth it. Rowling offers opinions on prejudice, courage, compassion and standing up for what wewe believe in. Twilight, I'm afraid to say, is quite unrealistic in a bad way. We see Edwards struggle, but it is not entirely believable, because we know that he will stay with Bella in the end. The vitabu glorify an unhealthy, unrealistic relationship and, although Meyer hardly ever describes her characters in a bad light (they are designed to be perfect, so that we can fawn over them), their actions are never as heroic au as honest as those that we see from the zaidi flawed, but zaidi believable characters in Harry Potter.
|
|