Maybe a mix of the two?

Neither.
Nice no matter what? Sounds like a doormat. You can be nice to someone but that doesn't mean you have to be nice to them no matter what they do.
Crazy and likes to play games? You mean like emotional games? People who treat other people like game pieces don't do anything for me.

^ Seconded.

Nice no matter what sounds like they lack emotional depth which is fine, but not attractive to me. Playing games is boring, too.

^^^ Nice as in always sweet, I mean obviously we all have our bad days and get grumpy, but like I'm not completely rude to someone if he's being a perv or an idiot. Likes to play games as in, likes to mess around and be goofy and is a little crazy in her actions and makes fun of sometimes but in a playful way (which I think is totally annoying in a girl if you like know what I mean) but it states that she understands a person well as in where he's coming from and stuff so she obvi wouldn't like treat him like a total game piece

^^^
Based on you're clarification, I have to say that I don't know who to choose.

A girl who is never rude to a guy who is being an idiot or a perv, worries me because what if he grabs her ass or something? She has every right to bitch slap him. Being polite all the time, regardless of how a person behaves is concerning behavior. In all honesty, I'd probably feel very protective towards a girl who did that. So I guess I'd find her more attractive...but I also feel uncomfortable being able to say that.

As for the other girl, what you've described is a girl with a sense of humor....actually she sounds like every girl I went to high school with. So that isn't a bad thing either, but it's a pretty generic description of a personality so it's hard to say if I'd be attracted to them or not.

Why does a female goofball or tease bother you so? It's good to have a bit of an edge...or something more descriptive than "nice no matter what"

^^^ I've just seen a lot of guys brush off or get mad at girls with attitudes or girls who tease a lot. I find it rather annoying cause they always act like they're in control of everything and it's rude, feminist way, even if the girl I'm having conflicts with tends to understand people well because of her past, she still is rude to people who get in her way and she doesn't have to be. Sure, being polite all the time can be concerning but it's how people at the top are expected to behave even if their rivals and sometimes it can come across as scarier than someone who teases or owns you (as in like, burns, ou know?) if you offend them. Actually, with guys, if a girl acts the way my rival does sometimes they dig her more ecase they think she's playing hard to get when in reality she just is super rude in her own world that she "controls". I guess she's not MEAN or anything, but she's just super crazy and does things weirdly and like is aloof or whatever. Its stupid.

its just my opinion tho u can have your own of course

Why do you think you have to prove to anyone that her way of doing things is 'wrong'? What difference does it make to you whether or not she's attractive? Maybe being attractive isn't a priority to her. Maybe she's just comfortable being herself and isn't worried about what people think of her? There's nothing wrong with that. Your description of her is very vague and seems colored by your own biases. When you think she's acting 'crazy' what is she doing? What does 'weird' or 'crazy' mean to you? Crazy behavior to me is very extreme- like jumping out of a moving vehicle. What's an example of something 'crazy' that she's done?
I think the lesson to be learned here is that it takes many different kinds of people to make up the world. Just because someone handles things differently than you do doesn't necessarily mean they're doing anything 'wrong'. I just means they have a different personality than you do.

I can get along with either one. The people that piss me off tend to be snobbish.

Why does it matter which one people are attracted to? You're not better than someone just because they're not your type.

^^